Critical Thinking Blog


How Many THINGS
Does One Guy Need?

August 19, 2010

Posts and comments received on this blog

 


Comments welcome. Click here to email.




How Many THINGS Does One Guy Need?

I think of myself as a minimalist. You know, buy just what you need. No foo-foo. No clutter. No unnecessary frills and flourishes. But then I started looking around at all the THINGS I'd accumulated over the years. Ugh. Reminded me of when, as a small boy, I'd go to Grandpa's garage and wander around the vast piles of disassembled car and truck parts, boards and wood scraps, stacks of half used paint cans, oily tarps, tomato stakes and garden tools, brushes and turpentine rags, glass jars of home canned vegetables, rusty cans of bolts and nails, unused brooms, old magazines, and unwanted chairs and dressers. Grandpa kept everything he ever owned. I do not.

As far as THINGS are concerned, my aim is to live the uncluttered life. My wife agrees. And from time to time we debulk. Bags of good clothing, household decorations, toys, kitchen wares and other THINGS we have neither used nor touched in the past year or two go to Goodwill.

We've replaced Caesar's,

"I came. I saw. I conquered" with

"I saw. I wanted. I purchased."


Good intentions should always be checked against facts. My hope was that I would find that I was living well with 100 THINGS or less. In my mind I began this way: Two cars, one cell phone, one computer, one printer, two TVs. Etc. Feeling good - that is until I opened my eyes and started actually counting. 50 shelves full of books averaging 40 books per shelf and I already was up to 2000 THINGS - books, half of them novels. Maybe I should count "books" as one THING.

And if there are 2000 books, along with a more than ample number of magazines and manila folders full of papers, what will I find when I stroll into the kitchen? How many cups, glasses, dishes, pots, pans, forks, spoons, bowls, cooking utensils, cans and boxes of food, dish towels, seasonings, dressings, fruits, cheeses, beverages and vegetables will I find? All totaled, the number will run well into the hundreds of THINGS. A peek at the linen closet will generate another bunch: sheets, towels, spare light bulbs, unused blankets, table cloths, etc. And there are my framed photos on the walls - my hobby is outdoor photography and we have poster sized prints from some of the beautiful cities, national parks and gardens we've been fortunate enough to have visited over the years. I don't dare look in the closet at all the shoes, ties, shirts, jackets, etc.!

"OK, critical thinker person," I'm thinking to myself, "how much is needed and how much is too much?" You can only sit in one chair at a time, only listen to one radio at a time, only sleep in one bed at a time, only ware one tie and jacket at a time. How many of those kinds of THINGS do you really need?

What really got me going on this was a visit to the Stanford Mall. Near the university, this particular mall caters to the very wealthy residences of towns like Palo Alto, Atherton, Burlingame and other peninsula cities south of San Francisco. We happened to be visiting a patient at the Stanford Hospital, which is adjacent to the mall. We had some time to kill and so we decided to stroll around and window shop a bit.

And, wow, what windows!

The Ralph Lauren store was loaded with white orchids, splendid furniture, and every possible accessory that someone hurrying from their morning visit to tennis club to their afternoon polo practice might need before returning home to dress for dinner and the symphony. THINGS! There was a bed with so many pillows, sheets, blankets, comforters, throws, and shams that it was not clear how a person could sleep there too. Another display featured a banquet table fully set for six. Each place setting included 20 things: place mat, charger, 3 plates, soup bowl, cup, saucer, five pieces of silverware, napkin, napkin holder, water glass, two wine classes, bread dish and butter knife. With the place settings, candles, flower centerpieces (plural), and baskets for breads and fruits, there was no room on that table to serve the meal. THINGS!

The mall, lavish with flowering plants, was crowded. You couldn't get near an i-phone at the Apple store because of all the people. There were lines at Starbucks. And there were people grazing through all the specialty shop. Do we really need all those specialty shops? Peer1 for toddlers? Banana Republic for middle school kids? A store that sells only candles? Another that sells only scented soap? Sports memorabilia for overweight ex-jocks? Do I really have to spend money to own a jersey signed by Joe Montana? Is that an "investment," or just plain silliness? What am I thinking as I pull my VISA card out of my pocket - is this THING really going to bring me happiness?

I'm no monk. No vows of poverty here, I assure you. But if critical thinking is about reflective judgment, then it must be the antithesis of impulse buying. We've replaced Caesar's, "I came. I saw. I conquered" with "I saw. I wanted. I purchased." Beef jerky at the checkout counter? When I stopped to put gas in my car was I really thinking, "Hum, I guess I'm hungry but just didn't know it. And, aha! - a Union 76 station - a great place to eat." In California we have great drinking water, fed by the snows in the Sierra Nevada's. Do I really need to buy bottled water when my tap water tastes as good or better?

You have to tip your hat to the power of clever marketing. Those visual merchandising, sales and design people are masters of getting us consumers to look right past the price. The consistent message is that whatever we already own isn't good enough. Get rid of that nasty thing you already have and spend some of your hard earned money to buy the same thing - water - back again.

Our clothing isn't stylish enough, you need this year's look. Ordinary fruits and vegetables aren't nutritious enough, you have to buy organic. Your car is so old it's a museum piece. The game will look so much better on your new HD TV. (By the way, it does.) Your body doesn't work, so you need pharmaceuticals and appliances to improve your digestion, sleeping, weight, blood pressure, strength, hair color, complexion, muscle tone, hearing, vision, breathing, sexual endurance, etc.

THINGS!

Would it destroy the economy and ruin the nation if we did not buy so many THINGS?

Do I need another newer … ?


Blog by Peter A. Facione, August 19, 2010.

Comments and Posts

Ryan Roth, allso a self-identified minimalists, writes:

Pete-

I've been both fortunate and unfortunate enough, depends on how you look at it, to have moved three times in the last four years. With each move I use the same approach when packing. I walk through the apartment asking myself, "Have you used this in the last six months? Will you use it in the next six months?" (This approach does not apply to item of sentimental worth.) When the answer is "No", I set the item aside for either donation or for the dumpster. This has definitely alleviated some of the clutter, and I have yet to look back with regret over a discarded item.

I too consider myself a minimalist -a minimalist in pursuit of maximizing utility. I am mostly a t-shirt and jeans type of guy (and thanks to Levi's clever marketing that will never go out of style…). Beyond that, I own a few plain or striped, button-down shirts, two pairs of dress pants (one gray, one black), and two suits (one gray, one black). My theory on clothing is that buying a timeless t-shirt or dress shirt (ones without patterns or flare) will allow me to span several fashion seasons without having to rush out and buy something new.

Between me and my roommate we have: 3 forks, 5 spoons, 5 knives, and a handful of cups, plates, and bowls -thankfully we have a dishwasher. We are both living a post-collegiate, bachelor lifestyle that doesn't concern itself much with hosting dinner parties and/or holiday gatherings. So I do understand that the contents of my cabinets (and wardrobe) will likely change/expand with time and as I "mature"; but for the time being, our limited amount of kitchenware is the perfect fit.

I think the number of THINGS a person "should" own is dictated by their place in life and their economic abilities. I like to believe I keep it simple in the world of consumerism, but I'm fairly certain that if I won the lottery today I would be out tonight on a shopping spree that would put Puff Daddy and Oprah to shame. This doesn't mean I NEED these THINGS, but it sure would be fun pretending I need a brand new Jaguar XK or an 81" flat panel HD TV.

-Ryan W. Roth


Oh, and this is a pretty funny quote:
"What is this obsession people have with books? They put them in their house - like they're trophies. What do you need it for after you read it?" - Jerry Seinfeld

Check out this blog and feel free to offer responses. click the blog link on the home page. dr. facione was one of the best professors i ever had. (ugh, hope he doesn't read this. that will be embarrassing). thanks.

Oops! Read it. Flattered and humbled too. Thanks, RR.

SC sent me this email:

HaHa, Thank you so much for writing this Dr. Facione. As I reflect on my own THINGS and how cluttered my two bedroom house is between me, my partner, and our 4 year old, I start thinking how much of these THINGS do we really need? And why do we always want more? More often than not I don't find reasonable answers to keep so many THINGS, (aside from some minimal sentimental value). Or finding a good reason to buy something new other than, "I liked it". Which really isn't a good reason at all.

At the end of the day I realize I came into this world stark naked and screaming with my fist balled EMPTY HANDED. And although ill probably leave this world much different than that, I probably wont be taking any of those THINGS! And yet again will leave this world EMPTY HANDED!

Was it really necessary to keep all those things through the years? Probably not. Sad part about it is I'm not even that old to have accumulated the amount of THINGS I have already. And between my clutter in 23 years of life, and the other random things my partner has collected in 30 years, and our 4 year olds amazing 100+ Thomas the train collection, I think we are in over our heads for MORE THINGS!

Now that it's Friday, when 430 hits and my weekend starts I just want to go home and throw THINGS away! Thanks for making me think about all the THINGS I wish I had, and realizing, why do I even need them when I have enough THINGS already just collecting dust and looking irrelevant.
-SC

Thanks, SC. And I love the image of the infant entering this world "fist balled yet empty handed."


Click to go back to the blog itself, "How Many THINGS Does One Guy Need?"







Views and opinions expressed in any posting on the "Critical Thinking Blog" are solely those of the contributor.
Measured Reasons LLC
Mailing Address:
PO Box 879
Redondo Beach, CA 90277
Phone: 650-743-8632

FAX: 310-379-5358
Noreen C. Facione, Ph.D.
nfacione@measuredreasons.com
Peter A. Facione, Ph.D.
pfacione@measuredreasons.com